• About

The Dunedin School

~ (2009 – 2014)

The Dunedin School

Category Archives: Reception

Mary MacKillop Rubbers Sold at the Melbourne Catholic Shop and Noah’s Ark in Australia

02 Tuesday Mar 2010

Posted by Deane in Reception, Religion

≈ 1 Comment

Tags

Ararat, Australia, Catholic kitsch, Mary MacKillop, Noah's Ark Road, rubber, Victoria

While I was in Australia last week, Mary MacKillop was canonised as the country’s first saint. Melbourne even has a special Mary MacKillop Shop, at which you can purchase all sorts of Catholic kitsch, such as a Mary MacKillop fridge magnet, or a Mary MacKillop charm spoon, and similar items of damnable popish idolatry. So I picked up one such item, proceeded to the counter, and announced, “I’d like to buy a Mary MacKillop rubber.” Catholic gasps of horror ensued, before the woman behind the counter looked at what I was holding in my hand and, breathing a sigh of relief, said, “Oh, an eraser! That’ll be 95 cents, please.” 

Noah's Ark Road, Ararat, Victoria, Australia

Noah's Ark Road, Ararat, Victoria, Australia

While in the thriving township of Ararat, Victoria, I had a play with the GPS to see if there was a Noah Street. Even better, there was a Noah’s Ark Road. As Ararat isn’t a very large town, I drove out to find it. (After all, I’ve read somewhere that fundamentalist Americans pay top dollar to go on Biblical Archaeology Package Tours to Ararat, in order to search for the remains of Noah’s boat.) It wasn’t much of a road – it was more of a farmer’s driveway, really, made only of red clay and about 5km long. And some jolly swagman had stolen the street-sign off the pole. The GPS told me I was there, though. I just checked, and Google managed to photograph the original street sign.

Advertisement

Prescribing things to symbols, with Wittgenstein

01 Monday Feb 2010

Posted by Deane in Reception

≈ 5 Comments

Tags

Adolf Hitler, Barbara Thiering, Kimbeley Cornish, Ludwig Wittgenstein, Notebooks, symbols, The Jew of Linz

A school photo of Wittgenstein & Hitler - according to the adventurous theory of Kimberley Cornish, a member of the Babs Thiering Down Under School of Hermetic Historiography

Wittgenstein & Hitler - According to the adventurous theory of Kimberley Cornish, a member of the Babs Thiering Down Under School of Hermetic Historiography

“You cannot prescribe to a symbol what it may be used to express. All that a symbol can express, it may express.”

– Ludwig Wittgenstein, in his Notebooks 1914-1916, numbered 130-131

Stars & Constellations and Potential & Actualized Meaning: Wolfgang Iser

22 Friday Jan 2010

Posted by Deane in Reception

≈ 13 Comments

Tags

constellations, determinate meaning, implied reader, indeterminate meaning, join the dots, Stanley Fish, stars, wolfgang iser

 

Wolfgang Iser sums up his theory of textual determinacy and indeterminacy with an analogy to stars and constellations:

 “… two people gazing at the night sky may both be looking at the same collection of stars, but one will see the image of a plough, and the other will make out a dipper. The ‘stars’ in a literary text are fixed; the lines that join them are variable.”
(The Implied Reader, 1974: 282)

Not bad – especially if you let the analogy extend a little, and note that even the stars will look slightly different to two different people, or to the same person in two different places, and recall that the stars are gradually moving apart from each other over time. For even the relative stabilities are somewhat unstable.

Not chaotically so, however. Against Fish, but loosening Iser’s distinctions a little, the success of Iser’s theory (more broadly conceived than does Iser) does not really “crucially” depend on an absolute distinction between determinate and indeterminate meaning, but on the degree of instability allowed for in the different modes of meaning-production. Stars may move, but do so in rather predictable fashions. The joining of stars is rather less predictable, if you’ve ever tried to work out how a group of stars could ever look like a ram, or how anybody ever came to the conclusion that a group of stars not only represented a woman but that the particular woman was a virgin!  

Against Fish, again, these two different modes of in/stability are not “just as variable” as each other, because they are fundamentally different in function. The ‘instability’ in the joining the dots between stars is nothing like the instabilities of the movement of the stars themselves or the changing nature of the star-gazer. Now, Fish’s criticism of Iser was quite valid on its terms (that is, Iser’s analogy about stars really does declare they are “fixed”). But a more charitable reader of the indeterminate gaps in Iser’s theory might have concluded that the basic distinction was also valid. There is something in the text which delimits meaning.

God for Clods

20 Wednesday Jan 2010

Posted by Deane in Hebrew Bible, Reception, Slang

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Aaron's rod, Chambers Slang Dictionary, comparative religion, Eve's curse, God for clods, Jonathon Green, zounds!

I noticed this while reading the Chambers Slang Dictionary (2008), by Jonathon “Mr Slang” Green. The slang phrase “God for clods” was allegedly used on U.S. campuses in the 1970s to describe “a course in basic comparative religion”.

Now that offers some groovy rebranding possibilities for RELS 101.

The Chambers Slang Dictionary provides more than a few entries with biblical allusions, most of them sharing a markedly Rabelaisian flavour. It all begins on the very first page, with “Aaron’s rod” (i.e. the penis, a term derived from Aaron’s blooming woody in Num 17.8) and extends through to the archaic “zounds!” (defined as “a euph. excl. lit. ‘God’s wounds'”).

One of the more visceral and memorable slang phrases containing a biblical allusion – of the ones I noticed in this engrossing dictionary – plays on the common and misogynist “menstrual interpretation” of Genesis 3:16, i.e. “the curse” of Eve. Here’s the delightful phrase:

“close as God’s curse to a whore’s arse [late 18C–early 19C] very close”

… yes, very close, indeed.

Tissot - God's Curse

James Jacques Joseph Tissot - 'God's Curse'

New Articles from The Dunedin School: Job; Aqedah; Achsah

27 Sunday Dec 2009

Posted by The Dunedin School in Continental Philosophy, Hebrew Bible, Postcolonialism, Reception, Violence

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

9/11, Achsah, aqedah, differend, divine violence, hybridity, Jean Baudrillard, Jean-François Lyotard, Job, suicide bombing, symbolic exchange, tangata whenua

Rounding up some recent articles emanating from The Dunedin School:

LyotardDeane Galbraith examines the book of Job through the lens of Jean-François Lyotard’s concept of the differend, uncovering a further dimension of injustice in the book resulting from God’s appeal to universalising and transcendent standards of divine justice which serve to deny justice to Job in the specific facts of Job’s dispute. He describes the book of Job as “the Bible’s most anti-Christian text”.
‘”Would you condemn me that you may be justified?”: Job as differend.’ Bible and Critical Theory 5.3 (October 2009)

BaudrillardEric Repphun explores the aqedah and divine violence in general, with reference to Jean Baudrillard’s theory of symbolic exchange. He questions whether suicide bombing, including 9/11 horrifies us, in part, not only because of its transgressing of the boundaries between the human and the inhuman, but also because “it violates the conventional logics of exchange rooted in capitalist ideas of exchange and use value”.
‘Anything in Exchange for the World: Jean Baudrillard, Jacques Derrida, and the Aqedah.’ International Journal of Baudrillard Studies 7.2 (July 2009)

Come Home (The Gift of Achsah)Judith McKinlay fleshes out the elliptical story of Achsah, a hybrid biblical character, in whose person and genealogy is an uncomfortable reminder of the tangata whenua (indigenous people) still in the land. “Forever located in Scripture, she is the pawn of an imperial hegemony…”
‘Meeting Achsah on Achsah’s land.’ Bible and Critical Theory 5.3 (October 2009)

Cyborg, Hauntology, Spectrality and the Bible

17 Tuesday Nov 2009

Posted by Deane in Biblical Studies, Ethics, Racism, Reception, Spectrality

≈ 11 Comments

Tags

blacks, chimpanzees, Chop Chop Chang, cyborgs, Donna Haraway, Ham, hauntology, Holloman Aero-Medical laboratory, Jacques Derrida, modernity, NASA, Nazi German, Racism, science, Space Chimps, Specters of Marx, Spectrality, Tyler, U.S. Space Program

The Bible does not exist as such. In opposition to the question, “Why drag the Bible in on a subject [Cyborgs, Hauntology, and Spectrality] with which it has absolutely no concern?”, I could ask, “What makes you think the Bible exists – except as hauntology – as that which haunts some current discourse, being both repetition and first time, thing and simulacrum?”

There are so many such current discourses from which to choose an illustrative example. But here is one concerning a chimpanzee, or more precisely, the naming of a chimpanzee.

In an expedition which is frighteningly reminiscent of the New World’s slave-trading past, in the 1950s, the U.S. Space Program sent an expedition to Cameroon, Africa to obtain baby chimps to train as the first astronauts to be sent into orbit. According to some reports, their chimpanzee mothers were slaughtered to obtain their babies. The chimps themselves, of course, were chosen because they were considered dispensible, less than people. And many of them died in space or in training.

Space Chimp, "Ham"What did they name the first African chimp to be sent into space? Ham. Officially, “Ham” is just an innocent name, merely the acronym of the Holloman Aero-Medical laboratory in which the chimps received their training to be astronauts. So there would be no equation of the African monkey with the ancestor of the cursed race of (Black) people of Christian tradition. But the apparent innocence of the acronym is shown to be haunted by centuries of racism when we consider that the name given to the second chimp in space was also chosen from our primeval ancestors. His name was Enos (the Hebrew term for “man”).

So here – at the pinnacle of human achievement, among the most scientific of men, and barely a decade after those previous most scientific men of Nazi German had achieved their scientific acme – is the spectre of a racist and biblical  past. It is also a racism thoroughly integrated with science. The implied progression from chimp to black to man (that is, white man) is inherent in the names used within the U.S. Space Program, just as it was among the early evolutionists and anthropologists. The three steps could easily have been derived from Edward Tyler’s own text-book. The pattern is already there in the Table of Nations, dividing the world into three parts, and providing a foundation myth to naturalize the inferiority and servitude of thousands upon thousands of other peoples. Modernity added the scientific nature of the racism, but the teleological ideology of science also has its traces in biblical apocalyptic.

Donna Haraway (she of Cyborg fame) identifies the link between space-chimp and biblical tradition:

“HAM’s name inevitably recalls Noah’s youngest and only black son.”

(The Haraway Reader, By Donna Jeanne Haraway, Published by Routledge, 2004: 92.)

Haraway understands the deep influence of the Bible in Western society. In this regard, she also notes that another chimpanzee in the U.S. Space Program, Chimp #65 was given the delightful name of Chop Chop Chang, “recalling the stunning racism in which the other primates have been made to participate” (94).

Today, as urgently as ever, we must speak with ghosts – engage in a spectral discourse – in order to identify injustices and in particular to identify the unfolding role of the Bible in creating injustice. In Jacques Derrida’s own, now spectral, words:

“No justice—let us not say no law and once again we are not speaking here of laws—seems possible or thinkable without the principle of some responsibility, beyond all living present, within that which disjoins the living present, before the ghosts of those who are not yet born or who are already dead, be they victims of wars, political or other kinds of violence, nationalist, racist, colonialist, sexist, or other kinds of exterminations, victims of the oppressions of capitalist imperialism or any of the forms of totalitarianism.”

(Specters of Marx: The state of the debt, the work of mourning, and the new international. Translated by Peggy Kamuf. New York and London: Routledge, 1994: xix.)

Space ChimpsFor if scholars refuse to recall ghosts, then the work may be left to others with much less critical memories, such as the memory-producing machine that is Hollywood. In the 2008 animation, Space Chimps, Ham III (the grandson of Ham) is picked by NASA for a space mission in which a group of chimpanzees must overcome the evil dictator Zartog on an Earth-like planet on the other side of the galaxy. Evil has been transferred to the other side of the galaxy, many light years from any association with NASA itself, who now appear on the side of intergalactic peace. That is one big transference of guilt! It need not be said that there is no explanation of the pejorative origins of Ham’s name and no appearance by Chop Chop Chang III the grandson of Chop Chop Chang. The institutional racism of NASA and of U.S. scientists has been forgotten and erased, purified and written out of the script. Wonder why? Perhaps somebody asked, “Why drag the Bible in on a subject with which it has absolutely no concern?”

The First Academic Conference on U2

16 Wednesday Sep 2009

Posted by Deane in Angels, Biblical Studies, Conferences & Seminars, Evil, Music, Reception

≈ 2 Comments

Tags

fallen angels, The Hype and the Feedback, U2

Unusual conferences are great! In a couple of weeks I’ll be flying out to Durham, North Carolina to take in the first academic conference on U2.

U2: The Hype and the Feedback

The conference program is here and includes stuff from a whole range of different disciplines. I’ll be presenting on fallen angels in U2’s music, and the interrelationships with ancient Jewish and Christian accounts – and mixing it up with some thoughts on how to avoid the ‘original versus deviant copy’ approach to reception history.

If you’re intrigued, come along! Registration is open to anybody who’s interested.

The Role of the Reader in ‘Tristram Shandy’

07 Monday Sep 2009

Posted by Deane in Literature, Reception

≈ 6 Comments

Tags

Laurence Sterne, reader response, Tristram Shandy

“Writing, when properly managed (as you may be sure I think mine is) is but a different name for conversation. As no one, who knows what he is about in good company, would venture to talk all; – so no author who understands the just boundaries of decorum and good-breeding, would presume to think all: The truest respect which you can pay to the reader’s understanding, is to halve this matter amicably, and leave him something to imagine, in his turn, as well as yourself. For my own part, I am eternally paying him complements of this kind, and do all that lies in my power to keep his imagination as busy as my own.”

(Laurence Sterne, Introduction to Vol 2, Chapter 11, The life and opinions of Tristram Shandy, Gentleman)

So, back in 1759, Sterne was already well aware of the competing roles of the reader and the writer within any good work of literature.

Top Posts

  • J.N. Darby's End-Times Family Tree: Is Dispensationalism from the Bible or Evangelical Tradition?
  • Dysenchanted Worlds: Rationalisation, Dystopia, and Therapy Culture in Ninni Holmqvist’s The Unit
  • Brainwashed into believing in a Moral Dictator called ‘God’: Caprica
  • About

Categories

  • Academics
  • Atheism and Agnosticism
  • Biblical Studies
    • Angels
    • Eschatology
    • Evil
    • Giants
    • Gnosticism
    • God
    • Hebrew
    • Hebrew Bible
    • Historical Criticism
    • Jesus
    • New Testament
    • Paul
    • Rabbinics
    • Reception History
    • Textual Criticism
  • Buddhism
  • Christianity
    • Theology
  • Conferences & Seminars
  • Dunedin School
  • Ecology
  • Ethics
    • Relativism
  • History
  • Islam
  • justice
  • Language
    • Metaphor
    • Reference
    • Rhetoric
    • Slang
    • Symbol
    • Translation
  • Living
  • News
  • Politics
    • Violence
  • Religion
    • Cults
    • Death
    • Exorcism
    • Faith
    • Fundamentalism
    • Healing
    • Prophecy
    • Purification
    • Rationalization
    • Visions
    • Worship
  • Texts
    • Cartoons
    • Comics
    • Film
    • Fine Art
    • Games
    • Greek
    • Internet
    • Literature
    • Media
    • Music
    • Philosophy
    • Photography
    • Pornography
    • Television
  • Theory
    • Capital
    • Children's rights
    • Continental Philosophy
    • Dialogic
    • Feminist Theory
    • Gender Studies
    • Intertextuality
    • Marx
    • Narratology
    • Postcolonialism
    • Psychoanalysis
    • Queer
    • Racism
    • Reception
    • Sex
    • Spectrality
    • Transhumanism
    • Universalism
  • Uncategorized
  • Zarathustrianism

Archives

  • September 2014
  • December 2013
  • September 2012
  • August 2012
  • July 2012
  • May 2012
  • April 2012
  • February 2012
  • January 2012
  • December 2011
  • November 2011
  • October 2011
  • May 2010
  • April 2010
  • March 2010
  • February 2010
  • January 2010
  • December 2009
  • November 2009
  • October 2009
  • September 2009
  • August 2009
  • July 2009

Recent Comments

  • Vridar » “Partisanship” in New Testament scholarship on Exposing Scandalous Misrepresentation of Sheffield University’s Biblical Studies Department and a Bucket Full of Blitheringly False Accusations: ‘Bewithering is Becoming Bewildering’*
  • Arthur Klassen on The Antichrist Revealed! John Key has been Prophesised in the Word of God!!
  • Anusha on Cinema as Exorcism (six): On Soft-Selling Lars von Trier’s Melancholia
  • Cary Grant on J.N. Darby’s End-Times Family Tree: Is Dispensationalism from the Bible or Evangelical Tradition?
  • Christian Discernment on The Antichrist Revealed! John Key has been Prophesised in the Word of God!!
  • fluffybabybunnyrabbit on Complementarians and Martial Sex: The Jared Wilson / Gospel Coalition Saga
  • lisawhitefern on The Antichrist Revealed! John Key has been Prophesised in the Word of God!!

Blogroll

  • Anthrocybib (Jon Bialecki and James Bielo)
  • Auckland Theology, Biblical Studies, et al
  • Dr Jim's Thinking Shop and Tea Room (Jim Linville)
  • Forbidden Gospels (April DeConick)
  • Genealogy of Religion (Cris)
  • Joseph Gelfer
  • Otagosh (Gavin Rumney)
  • PaleoJudaica (Jim Davila)
  • Religion and the Media (University of Sheffield)
  • Religion Bulletin
  • Religion Dispatches
  • Remnant of Giants
  • Sects and Violence in the Ancient World (Steve A. Wiggins)
  • Sheffield Biblical Studies (James Crossley)
  • Stalin's Moustache (Roland Boer)
  • The Immanent Frame
  • The New Oxonian (R. Joseph Hoffmann)
  • Theofantastique

Meta

  • Register
  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.com

Blog at WordPress.com.

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Follow Following
    • The Dunedin School
    • Join 47 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • The Dunedin School
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...