• About

The Dunedin School

~ (2009 – 2014)

The Dunedin School

Category Archives: Paul

John Barclay – The Unconditioned Gift

03 Saturday Apr 2010

Posted by Deane in Paul

≈ 1 Comment

Tags

gift, John Barclay, Paul

John Barclay, in the spacious surrounds of his office in the Burns Building, Dunedin's equivalent of the stunning Pruitt-Igoe Building

Professor John Barclay, currently residing in Dunedin, features in a one-page article today in Otago’s leading newspaper, The Otago Daily Times.

The article highlights some of John Barclay’s recent work on The Gift in the letters of Paul – a subject on which he presented earlier this week, in his fine De Carle Open Lecture series. Here’s an excerpt:

“”Paul has some radical notions about gift which arise out of the nature of the death and resurrection of Jesus, which make him break the mould of the ways in which people thought about and practised gift-giving in the ancient world,” he said. Gift-giving has become peripheral in modern Western society, and we consider the best gifts are unilateral, but for most other cultures past and present, a web of reciprocal gift-giving bound societies together. Over the past century, anthropologists and philosophers have studied how gift exchange operates in various societies, including Pacific and Maori societies, he said. “I’m trying to bring together that study and studies of Roman society and put Paul in that mix and ask what is Paul doing that is different; how does he think about the death and resurrection of Christ, and how does that challenge ancient notions of gift?” In societies where people tied themselves to others by giving and receiving gifts they had to be careful to whom they gave gifts. You gave to people according to their social status, who would enhance your reputation. There was no point in giving to insignificant people who were too poor or too worthless to tie oneself to in a gift relationship. The male, the free, the powerful and the rational were favoured over the female, slaves, the weak, poor or uneducated, he said. “So you have a set of interlocking hierarchies which determine how gifts are given. If this is so among humans, it’s all the more applicable to how God or the gods give.” Most religions had notions of sacrifice, which is giving to God or gods, and in doing so developing a gift relationship with them like that between a client and patron. People understood God or the gods maintained the proper order of the universe by giving gifts to fitting recipients with the right social, moral or intellectual qualities, he said. “Now one of the ways in which Paul’s thinking is very intriguing is that he interprets the life and death and resurrection of Jesus as a divine gift, but what is radical about it is that this is a gift given without preconditions, given in a way that flouts normal criteria of what is reasonable and sensible. “The sorts of values that are embedded in the way people give gifts in antiquity are deeply challenged by the way God’s gift is given to the unfitting, the undeserving, without regard to ethnicity, birth or lineage, without regard to moral status or achievement, without regard to gender, without regard to social status.””

Full article here: “The Unconditional Gift” (which should, rather, be entitled “The Unconditioned Gift”, to agree with JB’s understanding of Paul’s conception of the Christ-gift as a gift without precondition but with obligations).

Advertisement

John Barclay gives Open Lectures this month

20 Saturday Mar 2010

Posted by The Dunedin School in Conferences & Seminars, Paul

≈ 4 Comments

Tags

gift, John Barclay, Paul

John Barclay

Professor John Barclay, Lightfoot Professor of Divinity at Durham University (United Kingdom), famed New Testament scholar, and occasional Dunedin resident, will give (if you will pardon the pun) two lectures in the De Carle Open Lecture series, on Tuesday 30 March and Wednesday 31 March:

1. Paul and the Subversive Power of the Unconditional Gift
Tuesday 30 March, 5:10pm
Archway 1 Lecture Theatre, University of Otago

Working from the anthropology of gift, and the practice of gifts in Paul’s first-century context, a critical question emerges concerning who is qualified or worthy to receive the gift; answers on the gift’s proper distribution reveal foundational social norms. Paul’s mission to non-Jews broke Jewish ethnic and legal norms, and was the social corollary of his conviction that a divine gift (of Christ) had been given and distributed without qualificatory conditions. This conviction represents a highly unsettling perception of the world, at odds with the normal categories of hierarchy, quality and significance, and capable of creating irregular, socially creative communities. Paul emerges as one of the most subversive thinkers of the ancient world.

2. Paul, Reciprocity and the Modern Myth of the Pure Gift
Wednesday 31 March, 5:10pm
Archway 1 Lecture Theatre, University of Otago

The modern ideology of the pure, unilateral and utterly disinterested gift is the product of social and economic developments in Western history, strengthened by Protestant polemics and modern individualism. In Paul’s context, as in most traditional societies, gifts create obligations, are bilateral in exchange, and are a key mechanism for social integration. Paul’s ideology of gift-reciprocity in a community bound together by gift and need indicates that he is not a modern – and all the better for that! Special features of Paul’s notion of community-construction will be explored, with suggestions concerning their relevance to contemporary social and economic problematics.

All Welcome
And it’s free!

Derrida receives a crap Christmas present and contemplates his obligation to give one back.

Paul writing Jibberish

30 Wednesday Dec 2009

Posted by Deane in Paul, Television

≈ 3 Comments

Tags

jibberish, Paul

Paul Writing EpistleOne Jack Kilmon has a complaint about the way TV Bible-documentaries portray Paul writing his letters:

“Many of these documentaries, like “After Jesus,” flash back to and anchor themselves on a guy dressed in ancient garb with a reed in his hand, writing on papyrus to represent the Gospels or the Pauline epistles as the narrator discusses some historical event mentioned in those texts between discussions from some of the finest and most brilliant scholars and authors today… Now I can forgive the Medieval artists who depict the evangelists or Paul writing a text of scribbling or jibberish but in every one of these documentaries, not just one but all of them, the director does close-ups of the papyrus and the scribe dipping his reed and writing…what? Jibberish! Scribbles!”

So… the TV documentaries are portraying Paul as though he was writing jibberish? This might be just too obvious to even say, but: at least they are getting something right!

For complete historical accuracy, they then need to portray hordes of scholars across the span of the subsequent two millennia asserting that they have made perfect sense of Paul’s jibberish.

Top Posts

  • Cinema as Exorcism (four): Avatar as European Orientalist Fantasy
  • Tasting the Perimeter: The Porn Bible and God Loves Fags
  • The Antichrist Revealed! John Key has been Prophesised in the Word of God!!
  • Biblical Scholars in Pop Culture & The Media: (1) The Abominable Dr Phibes
  • God's Incarnation as a Donkey in Gerard Reve's Mystical-Sexual Fantasy
  • On Official Acceptance ...

Categories

  • Academics
  • Atheism and Agnosticism
  • Biblical Studies
    • Angels
    • Eschatology
    • Evil
    • Giants
    • Gnosticism
    • God
    • Hebrew
    • Hebrew Bible
    • Historical Criticism
    • Jesus
    • New Testament
    • Paul
    • Rabbinics
    • Reception History
    • Textual Criticism
  • Buddhism
  • Christianity
    • Theology
  • Conferences & Seminars
  • Dunedin School
  • Ecology
  • Ethics
    • Relativism
  • History
  • Islam
  • justice
  • Language
    • Metaphor
    • Reference
    • Rhetoric
    • Slang
    • Symbol
    • Translation
  • Living
  • News
  • Politics
    • Violence
  • Religion
    • Cults
    • Death
    • Exorcism
    • Faith
    • Fundamentalism
    • Healing
    • Prophecy
    • Purification
    • Rationalization
    • Visions
    • Worship
  • Texts
    • Cartoons
    • Comics
    • Film
    • Fine Art
    • Games
    • Greek
    • Internet
    • Literature
    • Media
    • Music
    • Philosophy
    • Photography
    • Pornography
    • Television
  • Theory
    • Capital
    • Children's rights
    • Continental Philosophy
    • Dialogic
    • Feminist Theory
    • Gender Studies
    • Intertextuality
    • Marx
    • Narratology
    • Postcolonialism
    • Psychoanalysis
    • Queer
    • Racism
    • Reception
    • Sex
    • Spectrality
    • Transhumanism
    • Universalism
  • Uncategorized
  • Zarathustrianism

Archives

  • September 2014
  • December 2013
  • September 2012
  • August 2012
  • July 2012
  • May 2012
  • April 2012
  • February 2012
  • January 2012
  • December 2011
  • November 2011
  • October 2011
  • May 2010
  • April 2010
  • March 2010
  • February 2010
  • January 2010
  • December 2009
  • November 2009
  • October 2009
  • September 2009
  • August 2009
  • July 2009

Recent Comments

  • Vridar » “Partisanship” in New Testament scholarship on Exposing Scandalous Misrepresentation of Sheffield University’s Biblical Studies Department and a Bucket Full of Blitheringly False Accusations: ‘Bewithering is Becoming Bewildering’*
  • Arthur Klassen on The Antichrist Revealed! John Key has been Prophesised in the Word of God!!
  • Anusha on Cinema as Exorcism (six): On Soft-Selling Lars von Trier’s Melancholia
  • Cary Grant on J.N. Darby’s End-Times Family Tree: Is Dispensationalism from the Bible or Evangelical Tradition?
  • Christian Discernment on The Antichrist Revealed! John Key has been Prophesised in the Word of God!!
  • fluffybabybunnyrabbit on Complementarians and Martial Sex: The Jared Wilson / Gospel Coalition Saga
  • lisawhitefern on The Antichrist Revealed! John Key has been Prophesised in the Word of God!!

Blogroll

  • Anthrocybib (Jon Bialecki and James Bielo)
  • Auckland Theology, Biblical Studies, et al
  • Dr Jim's Thinking Shop and Tea Room (Jim Linville)
  • Forbidden Gospels (April DeConick)
  • Genealogy of Religion (Cris)
  • Joseph Gelfer
  • Otagosh (Gavin Rumney)
  • PaleoJudaica (Jim Davila)
  • Religion and the Media (University of Sheffield)
  • Religion Bulletin
  • Religion Dispatches
  • Remnant of Giants
  • Sects and Violence in the Ancient World (Steve A. Wiggins)
  • Sheffield Biblical Studies (James Crossley)
  • Stalin's Moustache (Roland Boer)
  • The Immanent Frame
  • The New Oxonian (R. Joseph Hoffmann)
  • Theofantastique

Meta

  • Register
  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.com

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Follow Following
    • The Dunedin School
    • Join 47 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • The Dunedin School
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...