• About

The Dunedin School

~ (2009 – 2014)

The Dunedin School

Tag Archives: differance

Imagining the Postmodern

22 Tuesday Dec 2009

Posted by Deane in Biblical Studies, Historical Criticism, Theory

≈ 19 Comments

Tags

authorial intent, bias, binaries, body, bricolage, bullshit, deconstruction, diachronic, differance, epistemology, fad, free will, hegemony, hermeneutics, humanism, ideology, individualism, interpretive community, late capitalism, liberalism, metaethics, metanarrative, metaphysics, mind, objectivity, ontotheology, pluralism, polyvocality, post-structuralism, postmodernism, reader response, realism, Relativism, social construction, structuralism, subjectivity, synchronic, totalization, truth

From the current dialogue between historical critics and postmodernists, it’s fairly clear that:

(1) nobody agrees on the definitions of either historical criticsm or postmodernism, and yet 

(2) everybody is positioning themselves more on one side or the other, even if they don’t really buy the caricatures by the other side or even the appellations “historical critical” and “postmodern”.

Funny, eh?

So, in a (possibly futile) attempt to get a more precise fix on what people are holding onto dearly, or fervently objecting to, I’ve noted down a few of the so-called “postmodern” characteristics which are often touted, whether real or imagined.

Please let me know:
1. which of the characteristics are more imagined than real,
2. other characteristics that should be included here, or
3. which characteristics are the more important areas of contention, and why this is so

(and anything else that you really want to say, such as “why are you even bothering?”).

Concerning method:

  • Ideological criticisms (feminist, queer, postcolonial, etc) versus historical-contextual criticism
  • Partial, non-totalizing interpretations
  • Deconstruction (yes, as method!), post-structuralist identification of inherent problems with underlying binaries
  • Personal, subjective, or unevidenced responses versus empirical and logically argued criticism

Concerning metaphysical assumptions:

  • Anti-realism versus idealism
  • Anti-humanist/individualist/subject-centred conceptions; pro socio-cultural, intertextual, decentred self
  • Anti-free will; pro determinism
  • Anti-valorization of mind (rational, conscious, self-directing); pro-body (passions, desire, unconscious) anti-dualistic
  • Anti-metaphysics, ontotheology

Concerning epistemological assumptions:

  • Heightened sense of uncertainty, subjectivity, and bias of knowledge (empirical and rational, including scientific)
  • Increased recognition and opposition to paradigms, universalization, and metanarratives in knowledge acquisition
  • [Investigation of the historial constitution of types of knowledge/discourses, genealogy versus the search for history-in-itself and universal truths and unchallenged teleologies]
  • Anti-universal theories of knowledge, theories of everything, totalization, closure
  • Relativism, anti-foundationalism; anti-objectivity of truth
  • Anti- correspondence theories of truth; pro pragmatic or coherence theories

Concerning hermeneutical assumptions:

  • Post-structuralist, emphasising instability of language, differance, deconstruction, inherent contradictions, polyvocality
  • Anti-inherent or authorial textual meaning; pro reader response, interpretive communities for establishing meaning
  • Anti-naturalizing of categories; pro social construction
  • Focus on the final synchronic form rather than the earlier stages and diachonic issues

Concerning ethical assumptions:

  • Anti-metaethical justification – pro the event, the singular
  • Anti-consensus; pro pluralism, tolerance of difference
  • Anti-power, hegemony; pro marginalized, disempowered, excluded voices

Concerning aesthetic assumptions:

  • Bricolage, border-crossing, borrowing

Defined in relation to chronology and/or cultural phases:

  • Post WWI/Holocaust/1968
  • Late capitalism, hyper-commodification

As polemic:

  • A fad, buzzword
  • Crackpottery (voguish neologism attrib. to Chris Weimer)

Top Posts

  • Family First NZ: Jokes About Sexy Jesus Still Not Funny
  • Job, Adolf Hitler, and the Ethics of the Hebrew Bible: Or, why Philip Davies and Deane Galbraith are More or Less Wrong
  • Job, A God Not Quite Beyond Good and Evil, Unlimited Semiosis and Limitations of Meaning: Or, James Harding is Wrong, Wrong, Wrong, Wrongity Wrong
  • J.N. Darby's End-Times Family Tree: Is Dispensationalism from the Bible or Evangelical Tradition?
  • Dunedin's own Pruitt-Igoe: The Burns Building
  • The Antichrist Revealed! John Key has been Prophesised in the Word of God!!

Categories

  • Academics
  • Atheism and Agnosticism
  • Biblical Studies
    • Angels
    • Eschatology
    • Evil
    • Giants
    • Gnosticism
    • God
    • Hebrew
    • Hebrew Bible
    • Historical Criticism
    • Jesus
    • New Testament
    • Paul
    • Rabbinics
    • Reception History
    • Textual Criticism
  • Buddhism
  • Christianity
    • Theology
  • Conferences & Seminars
  • Dunedin School
  • Ecology
  • Ethics
    • Relativism
  • History
  • Islam
  • justice
  • Language
    • Metaphor
    • Reference
    • Rhetoric
    • Slang
    • Symbol
    • Translation
  • Living
  • News
  • Politics
    • Violence
  • Religion
    • Cults
    • Death
    • Exorcism
    • Faith
    • Fundamentalism
    • Healing
    • Prophecy
    • Purification
    • Rationalization
    • Visions
    • Worship
  • Texts
    • Cartoons
    • Comics
    • Film
    • Fine Art
    • Games
    • Greek
    • Internet
    • Literature
    • Media
    • Music
    • Philosophy
    • Photography
    • Pornography
    • Television
  • Theory
    • Capital
    • Children's rights
    • Continental Philosophy
    • Dialogic
    • Feminist Theory
    • Gender Studies
    • Intertextuality
    • Marx
    • Narratology
    • Postcolonialism
    • Psychoanalysis
    • Queer
    • Racism
    • Reception
    • Sex
    • Spectrality
    • Transhumanism
    • Universalism
  • Uncategorized
  • Zarathustrianism

Archives

  • September 2014
  • December 2013
  • September 2012
  • August 2012
  • July 2012
  • May 2012
  • April 2012
  • February 2012
  • January 2012
  • December 2011
  • November 2011
  • October 2011
  • May 2010
  • April 2010
  • March 2010
  • February 2010
  • January 2010
  • December 2009
  • November 2009
  • October 2009
  • September 2009
  • August 2009
  • July 2009

Recent Comments

  • Vridar » “Partisanship” in New Testament scholarship on Exposing Scandalous Misrepresentation of Sheffield University’s Biblical Studies Department and a Bucket Full of Blitheringly False Accusations: ‘Bewithering is Becoming Bewildering’*
  • Arthur Klassen on The Antichrist Revealed! John Key has been Prophesised in the Word of God!!
  • Anusha on Cinema as Exorcism (six): On Soft-Selling Lars von Trier’s Melancholia
  • Cary Grant on J.N. Darby’s End-Times Family Tree: Is Dispensationalism from the Bible or Evangelical Tradition?
  • Christian Discernment on The Antichrist Revealed! John Key has been Prophesised in the Word of God!!
  • fluffybabybunnyrabbit on Complementarians and Martial Sex: The Jared Wilson / Gospel Coalition Saga
  • lisawhitefern on The Antichrist Revealed! John Key has been Prophesised in the Word of God!!

Blogroll

  • Anthrocybib (Jon Bialecki and James Bielo)
  • Auckland Theology, Biblical Studies, et al
  • Dr Jim's Thinking Shop and Tea Room (Jim Linville)
  • Forbidden Gospels (April DeConick)
  • Genealogy of Religion (Cris)
  • Joseph Gelfer
  • Otagosh (Gavin Rumney)
  • PaleoJudaica (Jim Davila)
  • Religion and the Media (University of Sheffield)
  • Religion Bulletin
  • Religion Dispatches
  • Remnant of Giants
  • Sects and Violence in the Ancient World (Steve A. Wiggins)
  • Sheffield Biblical Studies (James Crossley)
  • Stalin's Moustache (Roland Boer)
  • The Immanent Frame
  • The New Oxonian (R. Joseph Hoffmann)
  • Theofantastique

Meta

  • Register
  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.com

Blog at WordPress.com.

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Follow Following
    • The Dunedin School
    • Join 47 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • The Dunedin School
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar